Buy wisely
Buy wiselyBuy wisely
For RetailersFor developers
  1. Home
  2. Fashion
  3. Shoes
  4. Women's Shoes
  5. Women's Sandals
  6. Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Buy wisely

BuyWisely is your one stop price comparison platform, delivering the best deals from over 5,000 online stores. We empower shoppers to make smart, cost-effective choices by offering transparent pricing, price history, and the latest deals across a broad range of products. With BuyWisely, your money goes further.

Popular Shops
Best Buy
Amazon
Walmart
Target
Home Depot
Costco
Newegg
Lowe's
Contact Us
andrew@buywisely.com.au
Affiliate Disclosure
Legal Information
Privacy Policy
Logos provided by Logo.dev
© 2026 BuyWisely•Price data powered by pricesAPI.io•Retailers: SellWisely.io
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40
Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40

Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40

Don’t like rigid posts between your toes? Give these supportive sandals with soft toe loops a try. Whether you pair them with a thick wool sweater and jeans or something dressier, they deliver the same flexible shock-absorbing base. Arch support and a deep heel cup cradle you through every step, because feeling good at sunset dance parties never goes out of style. Smooth and durable synthetic Birko-Flor leather uppers. 2 adjustable straps with buckles. Soft anatomically shaped cork latex core between jute layers for stability and moisture management. Suede leather lining provides a nice climate for your feet. Footbed edge is slightly raised to protect your feet from toe-stubbing. Toe bar guides your toes into place and promotes natural steps. EVA outsole for lightweight durability and absorbing shocks.

Don’t like rigid posts between your toes? Give these supportive sandals with soft toe loops a try. Whether you pair them with a thick wool sweater and jeans or something dressier, they deliver the same flexible shock-absorbing base. Arch support and a deep heel cup cradle you through every step, because feeling good at sunset dance parties never goes out of style. Smooth and durable synthetic Birko-Flor leather uppers. 2 adjustable straps with buckles. Soft anatomically shaped cork latex core between jute layers for stability and moisture management. Suede leather lining provides a nice climate for your feet. Footbed edge is slightly raised to protect your feet from toe-stubbing. Toe bar guides your toes into place and promotes natural steps. EVA outsole for lightweight durability and absorbing shocks.

Size:

5
6
8
8-8.5
10
10-10.5

Women's Birkenstock Mayari Footbed Sandals in Black Size US 9-9.5 / Birk 40

Don’t like rigid posts between your toes? Give these supportive sandals with soft toe loops a try. Whether you pair them with a thick wool sweater and jeans or something dressier, they deliver the same flexible shock-absorbing base. Arch support and a deep heel cup cradle you through every step, because feeling good at sunset dance parties never goes out of style. Smooth and durable synthetic Birko-Flor leather uppers. 2 adjustable straps with buckles. Soft anatomically shaped cork latex core between jute layers for stability and moisture management. Suede leather lining provides a nice climate for your feet. Footbed edge is slightly raised to protect your feet from toe-stubbing. Toe bar guides your toes into place and promotes natural steps. EVA outsole for lightweight durability and absorbing shocks.

Don’t like rigid posts between your toes? Give these supportive sandals with soft toe loops a try. Whether you pair them with a thick wool sweater and jeans or something dressier, they deliver the same flexible shock-absorbing base. Arch support and a deep heel cup cradle you through every step, because feeling good at sunset dance parties never goes out of style. Smooth and durable synthetic Birko-Flor leather uppers. 2 adjustable straps with buckles. Soft anatomically shaped cork latex core between jute layers for stability and moisture management. Suede leather lining provides a nice climate for your feet. Footbed edge is slightly raised to protect your feet from toe-stubbing. Toe bar guides your toes into place and promotes natural steps. EVA outsole for lightweight durability and absorbing shocks.

11
12
13
14
15
38
6 - 6.5

Price comparison

Price data powered by pricesAPI.io

Last updated at 03/21/2026 12:29:02

Englin's Fine Footwear

$160.37

Birkenstock Women's Mayari, Black Birko-Flor, 40R

Delivery $70.99

Famous Rock Shop

$175.00

Birkenstock Mayari Birko-Flor Black EU 40 Regular

Delivery $8

Premium Footwear Port Douglas

$189.95

Birkenstock Mayari Black Sandals - Stylish & Comfortable Black / 40

Free delivery

Price history

Price history

Reviews

Comfortable and stylish sandal!
4 July 2022Allie

originally posted on altitude-sports.com

I'm a long time buyer of Birkenstock sandals (been wearing my arizonas since 2009) and have owned many variations including the clogs, arizonas, and gizeh sandals. The Mayaris are a perfect cross of the comfort of the arizonas and style for the gizeh. I typically wear my Arizonas as they are the most comfortable style of Birkenstock I've tried and the gizeh to go with summer dresses but I prefer straps over the top of the foot rather than the thong/flip flop like sandals as those are harder on the feet after a long day. The Mayaris may be uncomfortable at first or may take some getting used to if you're not used to wearing straps around your big toe but once they're worn in they're a great fit. I find that during the break in period they can dig into the top of your ... MoreI'm a long time buyer of Birkenstock sandals (been wearing my arizonas since 2009) and have owned many variations including the clogs, arizonas, and gizeh sandals. The Mayaris are a perfect cross of the comfort of the arizonas and style for the gizeh. I typically wear my Arizonas as they are the most comfortable style of Birkenstock I've tried and the gizeh to go with summer dresses but I prefer straps over the top of the foot rather than the thong/flip flop like sandals as those are harder on the feet after a long day. The Mayaris may be uncomfortable at first or may take some getting used to if you're not used to wearing straps around your big toe but once they're worn in they're a great fit. I find that during the break in period they can dig into the top of your big toe joint depending on your gait/foot biomechanics. Overall would recommend to everyone who is looking for a comfortable sandal that looks great with cuter summer outfits!

Comfy, Very Poor Quality
5 October 2022RainyDay425

originally posted on nordstrom.com

These are unfortunately not at the typical Birkenstock standards that people perceive. My MIL wore themPeriodically/seasonally for a year and the cork on both soles is completely cracked where the ball of the foot lands and the leather strap broke on one side at the toe, and is 2/3 of the way cracked through on the other shoe. Very disappointed in the quality of this shoe with minimal wear on a very petite woman. For the amount of wear and length of time they lasted, I would be better served buying her shoes from Walmart. This was ridiculous. No warranty anymore through the manufacturer either on any Birk products.

Cute Shoes
31 July 2022GreenBagLady

originally posted on llbean.com

This is my first pair of Birkenstocks. They are very cute and they fit perfectly. I found my correct size by trying on in a local store. I've just started breaking them in by wearing inside for a short while at a time. This is not really the pair of Birkenstocks I wanted to order for 2 reasons. They are synthetic "leather" and I'm fairly sure real leather would be more durable. That may not even matter however because according to reviews of this style I have read on other sites, the toe loop often breaks before the rest of the shoe is worn out. I ordered it anyway because it is the only Birkenstock LLBean offers in the regular width. All the others are narrow, and although I always wear a regular B width shoe the narrow Birks don't work for me. I did get a great ... MoreThis is my first pair of Birkenstocks. They are very cute and they fit perfectly. I found my correct size by trying on in a local store. I've just started breaking them in by wearing inside for a short while at a time. This is not really the pair of Birkenstocks I wanted to order for 2 reasons. They are synthetic "leather" and I'm fairly sure real leather would be more durable. That may not even matter however because according to reviews of this style I have read on other sites, the toe loop often breaks before the rest of the shoe is worn out. I ordered it anyway because it is the only Birkenstock LLBean offers in the regular width. All the others are narrow, and although I always wear a regular B width shoe the narrow Birks don't work for me. I did get a great deal on these by using my Bean Bucks. And I hope they last for a long time. I just would really like for LLBean to carry the other styles in Birkenstock's regular width...

Specification

Footwear TypeSandals
Upper MaterialSynthetic
Outsole MaterialEVA
Closure TypeBuckle
GenderWomen

Price comparison

Updated 24 days ago
Englin's Fine Footwear

$160.37

Birkenstock Women's Mayari, Black Birko-Flor, 40R

Delivery $70.99

Famous Rock Shop

$175.00

Birkenstock Mayari Birko-Flor Black EU 40 Regular

Delivery $8

Premium Footwear Port Douglas

$189.95

Birkenstock Mayari Black Sandals - Stylish & Comfortable Black / 40

Free delivery

Price history

Price history

Reviews

Comfortable and stylish sandal!
4 July 2022

I'm a long time buyer of Birkenstock sandals (been wearing my arizonas since 2009) and have owned many variations including the clogs, arizonas, and gizeh sandals. The Mayaris are a perfect cross of the comfort of the arizonas and style for the gizeh. I typically wear my Arizonas as they are the most comfortable style of Birkenstock I've tried and the gizeh to go with summer dresses but I prefer straps over the top of the foot rather than the thong/flip flop like sandals as those are harder on the feet after a long day. The Mayaris may be uncomfortable at first or may take some getting used to if you're not used to wearing straps around your big toe but once they're worn in they're a great fit. I find that during the break in period they can dig into the top of your ... MoreI'm a long time buyer of Birkenstock sandals (been wearing my arizonas since 2009) and have owned many variations including the clogs, arizonas, and gizeh sandals. The Mayaris are a perfect cross of the comfort of the arizonas and style for the gizeh. I typically wear my Arizonas as they are the most comfortable style of Birkenstock I've tried and the gizeh to go with summer dresses but I prefer straps over the top of the foot rather than the thong/flip flop like sandals as those are harder on the feet after a long day. The Mayaris may be uncomfortable at first or may take some getting used to if you're not used to wearing straps around your big toe but once they're worn in they're a great fit. I find that during the break in period they can dig into the top of your big toe joint depending on your gait/foot biomechanics. Overall would recommend to everyone who is looking for a comfortable sandal that looks great with cuter summer outfits!

Allie originally posted on altitude-sports.com
Comfy, Very Poor Quality
5 October 2022

These are unfortunately not at the typical Birkenstock standards that people perceive. My MIL wore themPeriodically/seasonally for a year and the cork on both soles is completely cracked where the ball of the foot lands and the leather strap broke on one side at the toe, and is 2/3 of the way cracked through on the other shoe. Very disappointed in the quality of this shoe with minimal wear on a very petite woman. For the amount of wear and length of time they lasted, I would be better served buying her shoes from Walmart. This was ridiculous. No warranty anymore through the manufacturer either on any Birk products.

RainyDay425 originally posted on nordstrom.com
Cute Shoes
31 July 2022

This is my first pair of Birkenstocks. They are very cute and they fit perfectly. I found my correct size by trying on in a local store. I've just started breaking them in by wearing inside for a short while at a time. This is not really the pair of Birkenstocks I wanted to order for 2 reasons. They are synthetic "leather" and I'm fairly sure real leather would be more durable. That may not even matter however because according to reviews of this style I have read on other sites, the toe loop often breaks before the rest of the shoe is worn out. I ordered it anyway because it is the only Birkenstock LLBean offers in the regular width. All the others are narrow, and although I always wear a regular B width shoe the narrow Birks don't work for me. I did get a great ... MoreThis is my first pair of Birkenstocks. They are very cute and they fit perfectly. I found my correct size by trying on in a local store. I've just started breaking them in by wearing inside for a short while at a time. This is not really the pair of Birkenstocks I wanted to order for 2 reasons. They are synthetic "leather" and I'm fairly sure real leather would be more durable. That may not even matter however because according to reviews of this style I have read on other sites, the toe loop often breaks before the rest of the shoe is worn out. I ordered it anyway because it is the only Birkenstock LLBean offers in the regular width. All the others are narrow, and although I always wear a regular B width shoe the narrow Birks don't work for me. I did get a great deal on these by using my Bean Bucks. And I hope they last for a long time. I just would really like for LLBean to carry the other styles in Birkenstock's regular width...

GreenBagLady originally posted on llbean.com
Favorite Birks
19 May 2023

This is my favorite style of Birkenstock. I have tried the classic Arizona and the Gizeh. My foot slid too far forward in the Arizona and the Gizeh was uncomfortable between my toes. I tried to like them for two years before deciding they just weren’t making my feet happy. I have plantar fasciitis that makes shoe buying a pain, but otherwise normal feet. These shoes are light, comfortable, and versatile. I have had no issues with sore feet or uncomfortable rubbing. I’m very happy with them. I measure a 7.5 and bought a 37. It seemed like a small size to buy but they fit perfect.

Outdoorjunkie originally posted on famousfootwear.com
No foot pain with these
22 August 2022

I have ongoing plantar fasciitis and finally broke down and purchased Birkenstocks upon the suggestion of my podiatrist. I always resisted them because face it - they're ugly. Lately though, the designs have been cuter and come in a wider selection of colors. I bought these because the toe strap stops my feet from sliding over the front lip. The minute I put them on, my foot pain goes away. I wear them in the house from dawn to dusk and my foot never hurts. I guess my foot doc was right!

Mika originally posted on REI
So comfortable and yet stylish!
15 June 2023

I was searching for a sandal that would support my foot and still look great. This sandal is perfect for me. The straps are not leather which might be good as then I can walk in the wet grass with them. They will also be great to wear when I am standing for long periods of time. The first pair I received was defective (fixed toe strap different lengths) but the 2nd pair was good. Thank goodness for Altitudes easy returns. They fit a bit big.

Liz T. originally posted on altitude-sports.com
THEE most comfortable shoe ever
14 February 2023

When I first got these, and mind you it took an act of God to get me to buy them, I was encouraged to buy them as my feet needed a good shoe. The first two weeks I almost cried because they were so uncomfortable! But I read somewhere that they needed to be broke in, so I toughed it out. I have to say, I am so grateful for these shoes. THEE most comfortable sandle I have ever worn, I am a mess without them. I do have to say, the cork cracked by the big toe where the stap is. I hope I can mend them, but I was told these Birkenstocks last for years, so I will see how this goes!

SSCLARK originally posted on dsw.com
Terrific looking style.
15 May 2023

This is my first time purchasing Birkenstocks. I really like the look of the Mayari. I chose the Stone color. It is neutral, between a grey and brown. I like the crisscross style, which holds my foot in place since I usually have trouble with my feet sliding forward in sandals. These fit well and initially feel good walking around. However, my feet were sore after wearing them for several hours the first time. Maybe I need time to break them in. I’m hoping that’s it, since the description refers to the footbed eventually molding to your feet over time.

MJs Shoes originally posted on dsw.com
The most comfortable sandal I've owned.
10 December 2022

These shoes were great, they lasted three and a half years before obvious signs of wear started showing. I can still use them if I wanted but I'm upgrading to a new pair. I live in SoCal so they got year round use. They lived through lots of walking. I also wore them through a pregnancy, they were perfect when my feet would swell. I love these shoes and will be buying another pair soon. It did take a couple of days of breaking in when I first got them but it was worth it for the years of comfort they provided. So comfortable, supportive, and the mocha color is so versatile. You do have to take care of them by cleaning the footed and cork. At one point I had to buy a cork sealer to keep the cork from drying out too much. I honestly think they would have lasted long ... MoreThese shoes were great, they lasted three and a half years before obvious signs of wear started showing. I can still use them if I wanted but I'm upgrading to a new pair. I live in SoCal so they got year round use. They lived through lots of walking. I also wore them through a pregnancy, they were perfect when my feet would swell. I love these shoes and will be buying another pair soon. It did take a couple of days of breaking in when I first got them but it was worth it for the years of comfort they provided. So comfortable, supportive, and the mocha color is so versatile. You do have to take care of them by cleaning the footed and cork. At one point I had to buy a cork sealer to keep the cork from drying out too much. I honestly think they would have lasted long had I maintained them properly more often.

Cjrox originally posted on REI
These sandals will break your heart!
29 June 2022

Like all Birks, life with these sandals started off dreamy. They’re comfortable right out of the box. I went with a size 38 and I typically wear 8-1/2 in most shoes. Perfect fit! Over time though, the cork starts to crack on sides where the short strap over your big toe runs across the cork. This is true for the mocha and black pairs I have. But today, the strap over the big toe completely broke while in the grocery store. Purchased in October of 2020 and I live in the PNW so they only get summer use (June-Aug)—these shoes should last longer. If I were you, I’d buy the Arizonas instead. Sadly, the Mayari’s will break your heart!

Quistie S originally posted on REI

Specification

Footwear TypeSandals
Upper MaterialSynthetic
Outsole MaterialEVA
Closure TypeBuckle
GenderWomen